Speaking the board’s language: what three governance theories can teach fundraisers
As fundraisers we are used to the importance of understanding donor motivations and behaviours; we adapt our appeals to meet donor where they are. But how much consideration have you given to the motivations and behaviours of your board of trustees?
Your trustees influence your organisation’s access to resources, its accountability, its legitimacy and the organisation’s culture; these all impact on sustainable fundraising (Brown, 2005). Three governance theories can be useful when trying to get into the mind of your trustees. Take all three theories into consideration to reassure your trustees that you see them as more than just cash-machines: resource dependence theory, agency theory, and institutional theory
Resource dependence theory: focus on opportunity and influence
Resource dependence theory suggests that organisations rely on external resources for survival and that boards play a crucial role in accessing those resources; it’s the one we are most likely to think of. Trustees act as “boundary spanners”, connecting organisations to networks, information, influence, and funding opportunities (Brown, 2005; Miller-Millesen, 2003, pp. 522-523).
Advertisement
In the minds of many, and this may include your trustees, fundraising is simply asking for money and people can be uncomfortable with this. Trustees are more likely to be willing ‘boundary spanners’ if they understand your sophisticated approach to building and nurturing relationships, so take time to help them see how cultivation, solicitation and stewardship works. It is also a good idea to be specific with trustees about how they can help, and even better if you give them a way to self-evaluate their impact (Brown, 2005, p. 325).
Agency theory: focus on accountability and stewardship
Agency theory views boards as guardians of stakeholder interests (not the same as personal agency theory, e.g. Vallacher & Wegner, 1989). They are agents acting on behalf of the beneficiaries, but also donors, to deliver the promised outcomes. Their primary concern in this context is ensuring that organisational resources are used appropriately and in line with charitable purposes (Charity Commission, 2018)
Frame your requests to them in terms of strong accountability to stakeholders, including donors, which can increase confidence; now is the time to talk about the importance of reporting. Show you understand weak oversight can expose an organisation to financial misuse, reputational damage and lost support (Miller-Millesen, 2003).
Institutional theory: focus on legitimacy and trust
Institutional theory emphasises the importance of meeting the expectations of the external environment (ibid.). Boards help create legitimacy by adopting robust governance structures, processes for ethical conduct, offering diverse representation (Elmagrhi, Ntim, Malagila, Fosu, & Tunyi, 2018), and self-assessment. This reassures prospects that an organisation is well governed. While overlapping with agency theory in prioritising good practice, the audience here is the wider public, rather than just most influential stakeholders.
Fundraisers can use this insight by demonstrating how fundraising communications reinforce organisational credibility. Discussions with trustees should highlight ethical standards, regulatory compliance, transparency, and alignment with sector expectations .
Culture and timeframe
Miller-Millesen (2003) does not explore the role of the board in creating a culture of philanthropy (Cavanah, 2017; Gibson, 2016), which is increasingly recognised as an important role.
Miller-Millesen’s (2003) reference to life-cycle is particularly interesting in the context of fundraising, as illustrated in the paper by Kay‐Williams (2000, In: Breeze, Day Lafferty, & Wiepking, 2023). In this paper she outlines the changing relationship between the charity founder, board and its fundraising function.
Bibliography
Breeze, B., Day Lafferty, Donna, & Wiepking, P. (2023). The Fundraising Reader: Routledge.
Brown, W. A. (2005). Exploring the association between board and organizational performance in nonprofit organizations. Nonprofit Management and Leadership, 15(3), 317-339.
Charity Commission, of England and Wales. (2018). The essential trustee: what you need to know, what you need to do (CC3). London, GB: Gov.UK Retrieved from https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/866947/CC3_feb20.pdf.
Elmagrhi, M. H., Ntim, C. G., Malagila, J., Fosu, S., & Tunyi, A. A. (2018). Trustee board diversity, governance mechanisms, capital structure and performance in UK charities. Corporate Governance: The international journal of business in society, 18(3), 478-508.
Miller-Millesen, J. L. (2003). Understanding the behavior of nonprofit boards of directors: A theory-based approach. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 32(4), 521-547.
Vallacher, R. R., & Wegner, D. M. (1989). Levels of personal agency: Individual variation in action identification. Journal of Personality and Social psychology, 57(4), 660.
