No Such Thing as a Free Gift: The Gates Foundation and the Price of Philanthropy
The Gates Foundation is the largest private foundation in the world, spending more on global health than many national governments. But is it doing what it claims? And at what cost — to democracy, to public health systems, and to the communities it says it serves? University of Essex sociologist Linsey McGoey’s forensically researched investigation puts the new golden age of philanthropy under the microscope.
When Bill and Melinda Gates began giving away their vast fortune, it was widely celebrated as enlightened generosity on an unprecedented scale. Today, the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation funds global health programmes, agricultural development in Africa, and education reform across the United States. It often spends more than the governments of the countries in whose name it acts.
For many, this is philanthropy at its finest. For Linsey McGoey, it raises urgent and largely unasked questions about power, accountability, and democratic legitimacy.
No Such Thing as a Free Gift is a work of careful, historically grounded sociology. McGoey traces the history of American mega-philanthropy from Andrew Carnegie and John D. Rockefeller through to the present day, showing how the tax and legal frameworks that made large-scale charitable foundations possible were constructed. And how the same frameworks have been used to advance private interests under the cover of public good.
She places the Gates Foundation in this long context, and then examines its record in global health, agriculture, and education with meticulous attention to evidence.
Not conspiracy but a concentration of power
What she finds is not conspiracy but something in some ways more troubling: a set of structural incentives that consistently lead large philanthropic institutions to concentrate power, displace local knowledge and democratic decision-making, and create dependencies that outlast any given programme.
The Gates Foundation’s agricultural initiatives in Africa have benefited US agribusiness; its education reform agenda in the United States has advanced the interests of its corporate partners; its health funding has, at times, distorted the priorities of the World Health Organization.
McGoey does not argue that Gates is malevolent: she argues that the system itself is the problem.
Since the book’s first publication in 2015, its arguments have gained new relevance. Questions about the accountability of philanthropic mega-foundations have moved from the margins to the mainstream of public debate, and the Gates Foundation’s interventions during the COVID-19 pandemic brought its influence, and its limitations, into sharp relief. No Such Thing as a Free Gift remains the most rigorous and complete examination of that influence yet published.
About Linsey McGoey
Linsey McGoey is Professor in the Department of Sociology at the University of Essex. She has been a member of the World Health Organization’s expert steering group on the impact of a human rights-based approach to health, and has previously held research fellowships at the University of Oxford.
She has written for the Guardian, Open Democracy, the Spectator, and Globe and Mail. Her subsequent book, The Unknowers: How Strategic Ignorance Rules the World, was published in 2019.
Reviews
“The charitable model represented by the Gates Foundation is failing to address the root causes of inequality and ecological crisis. This path-breaking book is a sorely needed, historically grounded investigation into the difference between philanthropy and justice.”
Naomi Klein, author of This Changes Everything and The Shock Doctrine
“Impeccably researched and beautifully written — the best and most complete examination of the Gates Foundation and the workings of big philanthropy. A must-read for anyone concerned with where the world is heading.”
Michael Edwards, Distinguished Senior Fellow, Demos
“A brave, intelligent and important book that raises vital questions about the full impact of a key source of the world’s public health funding.”
Arthur Caplan, New York University
“A lively and well-argued antidote to the comfortable but superficial assumption that giving money away is, by definition, good.”
Third Sector
“Rather than spin far-fetched conspiracy theories, she simply shows what the oligarchs are doing in plain sight, which is frightening enough.”
Jonathan Rose, author of The Intellectual Life of the British Working Classes
Related books on UK Fundraising
- Winners Take All (Giridharadas) for a broader critique of elite philanthropy;
- Philanthrocapitalism (Bishop & Green) for the case in favour;
- Dark Money (Mayer) for the political weaponisation of philanthropic structures;
- Limitarianism (Robeyns) for the philosophical foundations.
Cover image: https://www.versobooks.com/products/129-no-such-thing-as-a-free-gift
Buy on Bookshop.org Buy on Amazon 