Fire in the Heart of the City: The Triangle Shirtwaist Tragedy and the Origins of Modern Charity
A new narrative history argues that the 1911 Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire was a founding moment for modern charity as well as for labour reform, and that the argument over who should lead New York’s response still shapes how we think about poverty and giving.
The Triangle Shirtwaist fire is usually told as a labour history story. In Fire in the Heart of the City, historian David Conrad-Pérez argues that it was also a turning point for charity.
In the days after the fire, which killed 146 garment workers, a dispute broke out over who should lead the city’s response. On one side stood a rising charity sector led by wealthy financiers and civic elites, with New York Times publisher Adolph Ochs as a key figure. On the other were the unions and reformers of Lower Manhattan, including the labour organiser Rose Schneiderman.
The book traces how the Times and its philanthropic allies promoted a “scientific” model of charity that claimed expert authority over poverty and immigration. Conrad-Pérez argues that this model drew on eugenics-influenced assumptions, treating poor and immigrant communities as populations to be classified and managed rather than as people with a say in the response.
The research draws on newly released archives, previously confidential reports, private diaries and correspondence, and interviews with descendants of Ochs and of labour organisers.
For fundraisers, charity leaders and indeed civil response leaders in local government, the questions are still live: who defines need, who holds power over the response, and whose voices are heard when a charity speaks for a community?
A history of how the modern charity sector took shape, and of the arguments that surrounded its birth, makes useful reading for anyone who wants to understand the sector’s foundations and its blind spots. It is a US story, but one that UK fundraisers will recognise in many of today’s debates about power, expertise and legitimacy.
Listen to the author on Philanthropisms
Conrad-Pérez is interviewed by Rhodri Davies on the Philanthropisms podcast, discussing the fire, the labour movement, the role of the New York Times, the rise of scientific charity, and what today’s philanthropy can learn from this history.
There is also an episode page on Why Philanthropy Matters.
About David Conrad-Pérez
David Conrad-Pérez is a historian and narrative nonfiction writer. He spent about ten years in journalism, with work published in The New York Times, Los Angeles Times and Columbia Journalism Review, and worked as a producer for Public Radio International’s The World and WNYC’s On the Media.
He holds a PhD from the University of Pennsylvania, where he researched the origins of modern news institutions, and is Research Director at the Center for Media & Social Impact at American University. More at davidconradperez.com.
Reviews
“This absorbing historical analysis of the confluence of labor, elite media, and social reform movements, and not the least, the workers themselves, is a must read for all engaged in the efforts to understand how the present came to be.”
Yoosun Park, professor of social work and author of Facilitating Injustice
“Fire in the Heart of the City tells the story of an awful and quite preventable tragedy that galvanized the labor movement and led The New York Times to respond with an appeal for charity instead of justice. David Conrad-Perez is an engaging writer who brings this intense and infuriating history to life, while offering a striking reinterpretation of the Triangle fire and its lasting consequences.”
Michael Kazin, professor of history, Georgetown University and author of What It Took to Win: A History of the Democratic Party
Related books on UK Fundraising
- Philanthropy in America: A History (Zunz)
- Julius Rosenwald: The Man Who Built Sears Roebuck and advanced the cause of black education in the American south (Ascoli)
- Madam CJ Walker’s Gospel of Giving
![[ad] Fundraising Everywhere Trusts and Major Donors Conference December 2026](https://wfay6x.infiniteuploads.cloud/2026/09/fundraising-everywhere-trusts-conference-202612-728x90-1.jpg)