# Where is the future for fundraising? Regulation, or empowerment?

- Link: https://fundraising.co.uk/2016/06/30/future-fundraising-regulation-empowerment/
- Published: 2016-06-30T12:27:19+01:00
- Author: Giles Pegram CBE

**The future must focus on the relationship between donor and cause, not on fundraising
technique. We have got to put the donor first, not the charity. Then we can do most
to help beneficiaries.**

 

That is not, I believe, where we are. We need a change in direction. And such a 
change requires a catalyst. Where is that catalyst? What will be the trigger for
change?

## Advertisement

 

Over the past year, much has become clear. We have a problem. We, as fundraisers,
were responsible. Not just a few rogue charities; all of us. The media exposed it.
In my view, they didn’t create the distrust and disquiet that donors have in charities;
they confirmed something that was already there.

 

So there was a reaction. Standards, controls, sanctions, re-set buttons, an obligation
to opt-in, greater requirements for trustees and so on.

 

Has the response to bad practice been measured, correct and appropriate? Or an over-
reaction? Probably the latter. What has surprised me in all the furore is that no-
one has reported the impact that all the new regulation will have on the beneficiaries.
How many will not be helped because of a possible over-reaction? It has not been
a zero-sum game.

 

We need to turn the current situation on its head.

 

At the moment we have identified a problem and moved backwards. We’ve been told 
off. Told we mustn’t do it again, or there’ll be trouble. Been defensive. Looked
for compromise.

 

This may have been needed.

 

But now, we should recognise the problems, and move forward. Not see fundraising
as inherently bad, to be controlled, but as something that is inherently good, to
be encouraged. Make fundraising brilliant. Make us all feel proud to be fundraisers.

 

Ken Burnett and I met to discuss this before the Olive Cooke story broke. We felt
that all the evidence was that people wanted to be _relationship fundraisers_, but
didn’t really know how. _Relationship fundraising_ has always been much talked about,
but not really implemented. We wanted to do something. We believed things could 
be changed for the better. Then the Olive Cooke story gave us an added impetus.

 

And so the [_Commission on the Donor Experience_](https://fundraising.co.uk/2015/10/01/commission-on-the-donor-experience-to-put-donors-back-at-the-heart-of-fundraising/)
was born.

 

Our aim is to transform fundraising, to change the culture to a truly consistent
donor-based approach to the business of raising money.

 

A huge aspiration. But we now have:

 

 * 12 Commissioners. Drawn from the media, communicators, trustees, CEOs, appeals
   directors, fundraisers and donors.
 * A full-time director.
 * The underpinning aims.
 * 25 projects, each with a project owner, amongst the best in their field.
 * Many contributors to the projects.
 * And some 600+ ‘enthusiasts’ on board, helping where they can

 

I believe the Commission is the catalyst I referred to above. The trigger for change.

 

 

 

The thing that could leverage the transformation of fundraising.

 

When we launched the Commission in March, people said: _‘yes, but how?’_   We have
spent six months listening, drafting and consulting.   Involving the best minds.

 

We have now said ‘how’.   Not the answer, but a description of what the answer will
look like.   And, after much discussion, debate and refinement, we have produced
the scope of the Commission.

 

Up to now, we have been opening up.   Now, we begin to close down.   To do the work,
consult with donors (imperative) and get the work reviewed by independent reviewers.

 

Good enough is not good enough.

 

Please read the [project zone](http://www.donor-experience.com/Pages/Category/projects).
Even if you haven’t time to read this, please be ready for the final report.

 

Let me give you a few examples of the projects.

 

## Satisfaction and commitment

 

Traditionally fundraisers measure success in money raised now. But as indicators
of long-term commitment several factors are more important and more useful than 
the ubiquitous, historic RFV tool (recency, frequency and value). This project will
create a practical guide to measuring these other main indices and will show where
relevant research and examples of best practice can be found

 

## Giving choices and managing preferences

 

There is clear evidence that giving donors practical control over how they relate
to and hear from fundraisers can be highly effective in improving both the donor
experience and fundraising results. This project will look at the systems that have
been implemented and the results they’ve achieved, with the aim of defining an ideal
approach that offers donors practical choices and real control over the shape of
their relationship with individual causes.

 

## The role of trustee boards and senior management

 

Fundraising’s evolving future will inevitably have profound implications for volunteer
boards and senior management teams. This project will help them to understand the
changes in their roles and to prepare for, contribute to and respond to fundraising’s
new agenda.

 

## Fundraising investment

 

Donors often express concern about any money being spent on fundraising, despite
evidence that appropriate investment in fundraising enables their contribution to
be more effective by leveraging further donations. This project will identify the
extent to which donors’ concerns on this topic are a barrier to giving, and how 
better fundraising practice can ensure that the ‘the truth told well’ about fundraising
costs can reassure those donors who are willing to engage with the issue.

 

## The use and misuse of emotion

 

Fundraising is inevitably emotional and emotion is hugely powerful, so must be used
responsibly and wisely. This project will consider whether and how emotion can be
safely used in fundraising communications. It will define the opportunities and 
responsibilities that come with telling the truth well, with power and passion that
can move people to action

 

## Evidence of impact and effectiveness

 

Every donor’s most pressing question is, ‘will my gift make a difference?’ This 
project will look at all of the ways charities can become known for inspiring, quality
feedback that proactively brings this difference to life by showing donors what’s
achieved when they generously give their support.

 

 

 

None of this is rocket science. But it requires change. The 25 projects are mutually
reinforcing. The outputs of the Commission, taken together, could make a huge difference.
That difference won’t happen overnight. It will take years, possibly many.

 

How do we embed the outputs into the sector? How do we ensure this is not tomorrow’s
fish and chip wrapper? (Or whatever the digital age equivalent is.) We still need
to work out the detail. But:

 

 * We need to ensure that chairs of trustees, trustees, CEOs, fundraising leaders
   and fundraisers are aware of the final report. And encourage them to change.
 * We will make as much noise as we can. And we will promote it through our army
   of enthusiasts.
 * We plan to ensure the output is kept alive, long after the Commission’s work 
   is finished and the output is in the public domain.

 

This is not about charities. It’s about need and beneficiaries, and the donors who
want to be part of the solution to that need. It’s about the role of fundraisers
in linking them. And the obstacles we, as fundraisers, often put in front of donors,
by focussing just on asking, not on how the donor feels, the experience she is having
or the difference she is making. It’s about the practice that will enable us to 
make sure donors have a better experience so that they’ll want to give more and 
do more for beneficiaries.

 

Why else do we exist?

 

Is fundraising an activity that needs to be regulated? Of course. As is driving 
a car, practising as a doctor or fixing people’s boilers. But we shouldn’t become
obsessed with regulation. That is, for some of us, what has happened? We must change.

 

Fundraisers connect donors to causes. If we make donors feel that they are having
a good experience they will give more. [They will feel empowered](https://blog.curriculosolutions.com/student-empowerment-achieving-success-once-you-graduate)
and that they are making a difference. More beneficiaries will be helped.

 

That is what fundraising should be about.

 

The CDE sounds obvious. _“Give donors a better experience and they will give more”._
But it is much more than that. The output of the Commission will not only give guidance
on how to behave differently but also think differently. And, I believe, that is
what we must do.

 

© 2016 Giles Pegram CBE
