# Improving your fundraising without the risk

- Link: https://fundraising.co.uk/2009/02/17/improving-your-fundraising-without-risk/
- Published: 2009-02-17T10:36:11+00:00
- Author: Howard Lake

 

We can all improve our fundraising performance but the options we have in today’s
climate seem to be polarised.  Completely entrench and try and wait the recession
out or ‘revolutionise’ to make a big splash and out-shout the competition. 

 

## Advertisement

 [⌊Posthub advert. You create the campaign. We'll handle the postal journey. Get started at post-hub.co.uk.⌉](https://fundraising.co.uk/ads/posthub-20261007-300x250/)

 

 

I’m not sure either is preferable and instead offer the following for your thoughts
and comments.

 

 

 

The temptation is often to seek outside help – not necessarily a bad thing as long
as it’s the right kind of help.  The wrong kind of ‘expert’ doesn’t spend much time
trying to understand your organisation and your specific needs, so what do they 
tell you?

 

 

 1. "Eliminate Campaigns A and B!"
 2.  "Replace them with Campaigns X and Y!"

 

 

Having followed the recommendations, you analyse the results six months later to
find that the revolutionary ideas didn’t work as well as expected.  Therefore you
revert to what you had been doing previously for the next tranche of activity.  
Whilst this might be better than trying something completely new, it does mean you
are back with the mediocre results you were trying to improve upon in the first 
place.

 

 

 

In my experience, transformational change programmes often fail because of a simple
misconception; true revolution rarely actually happens (and if it does, it often
requires significant awareness campaigning to bring the audience along the journey
too).  What seems to produce much better results is piling up small wins on top 
of each other to improve results overall.

 

 

 

A touch of evolution that you control instead of revolution!  So, how do you pile
up the small wins?  Play the "Defeat the Champion" game (a.k.a. A/B Testing).

 

 

 

Think of A/B testing like a boxing championship; the organisers consistently line
up fighters to see who can defeat the champion.  But this is done one match at a
time so the focus is only ever on the next result – the incremental improvement.
For instance:

 

 

 1. The winner of a World Title Match fights the next top contender
 2. The winner of that Title Match fights the next top contender 
 3. Repeat step 2.

 

 

Link this to fundraising activity and campaigns:

 

 

 1. Determine what you want to improve (e.g. better direct marketing results)
 2. Determine your current champion (e.g. the existing new donor acquisition pack)
 3. Play the "Defeat the Champion" Game (e.g. create a new pack to send to a representative
    sample of the same audience group, perhaps in a 50/50 split with the existing pack)
 4. Compare the results in terms of overall number of responses, amount generated, 
    average value per donation etc. and see if you have a new champion
 5. Repeat this exercise with the next campaign so you are continually seeking to evolve
    your results and don’t risk ‘throwing the baby out with the bathwater’.

 

 

You can play the game with almost every aspect of your fundraising activity:

 

 

 * the best direct mailing or emailing campaign overall
 * the best creative design
 * the best audience to target
 * the best level of ask for any given campaign 
 * the best time to communicate with the audience
 * the best celebrity to associate with the activity
 * etc.

 

 

Key to success is not changing too much at once and keeping a control measure in
place.  That is, try to only change one significant factor per test and keep an 
element of the current champion in every campaign so you have a baseline to compare
performance.  If you are delivering integrated emailing and SMS campaigns and you
change the target audience, data supplier, timing and creative, how will you know
which factor impacted on the results?

 

 

 

The moral (if there is one):

 

 

 1. Don’t eliminate things that already work 
 2. Instead, try to produce things that work better and use the current champion’s 
    performance as your benchmark 
 3. Invest future resources into what you therefore know works best and incremental
    improvements simultaneously

 

 * **[Don't forgive forgetfullness](https://fundraising.co.uk/2009/02/18/don039t-forgive-forgetfullness/)**(
   18 February 2009)
 * **[WSPA Director of International Marketing to join UNHCR](https://fundraising.co.uk/2009/02/19/wspa-director-international-marketing-join-unhcr/)**(
   19 February 2009)
 * **[Amanda Ball to be Group Marketing Director at merged age charity](https://fundraising.co.uk/2009/02/20/amanda-ball-be-group-marketing-director-merged-age-charity/)**(
   20 February 2009)