# Report says aid agencies exaggerated southern Africa crisis

- Link: https://fundraising.co.uk/2004/01/17/report-says-aid-agencies-exaggerated-southern-africa-crisis/
- Published: 2004-01-17T00:00:00+00:00
- Author: Howard Lake

A report by consultants Valid International for the Disasters Emergency Committee
has found that international aid agencies overstated the food crisis in 2002-03 
in southern Africa. Some of their fundraising appeals were therefore misleading.

The report into the 12 charities that make up the Disasters Emergency Committee 
acknowledges that many lives were saved by the charities, but points out that a 
number of mistakes were made.

Two appeals by the British Red Cross for work in Zimbabwe were criticised for using
the word “famine”, and World Vision and Tearfund were found to have incorrectly 
compared the crisis to that of the 1984 Ethiopian disaster.

Some charities were commended for their approaches, including Save the Children 
Fund and Cafod.

## Advertisement

The independent report noted that the complex situation resulted in tensions between
charities’ field staff and marketing staff in the UK.

The report looked at the charities’ work with local organisations and highlighted
mistakes there too.

Overall however the report has been welcomed by the DEC which judged the appeal 
and the work it funded, in what was a complex situation, to have been successful.
The criticisms of the report would be acted on.

 * **[Salvation Army in USA to receive $1.5 billion gift](https://fundraising.co.uk/2004/01/21/salvation-army-usa-receive-15-billion-gift/)**(
   21 January 2004)
 * **[National misTrust Web site](https://fundraising.co.uk/2004/01/22/national-mistrust-web-site/)**(
   22 January 2004)
 * **[New e-mail worm uses charity e-mail addresses to trick recipients](https://fundraising.co.uk/2004/01/29/new-email-worm-uses-charity-email-addresses-trick-recipients/)**(
   29 January 2004)