# Strategy Unit report is largely welcomed

- Link: https://fundraising.co.uk/2002/09/25/strategy-unit-report-largely-welcomed/
- Published: 2002-09-25T23:00:00+01:00
- Author: Howard Lake

The Strategy Unit has reported its recommendations on overhauling the 400-year-old
law on charity in England and Wales.
The Strategy Unit report on the legal and regulatory
framework of the

non-profit sector is an impressive and thought-provoking document. In CAF’s

view, the report raises a number of fundamental issues all of which are

## Advertisement

 [⌊Posthub advert. You create the campaign. We'll handle the postal journey. Get started at post-hub.co.uk.⌉](https://fundraising.co.uk/ads/posthub-20261007-300x250/)

important for the future of charities and voluntary organisations.

CAF will be consulting widely and will be issuing clear statements as to its

views on a variety of proposals highlighted in the report. For example, CAF

will produce a detailed response on accountability and transparency within

the sector, the potential role of social enterprises and community

businesses and the legal statutes surrounding this activity and the future

role of the Charity Commission – amongst other subjects. CAF will play a

full role in the consultation period and will be looking to take

initiatives, with other bodies, to push forward the agenda.

The Strategy Unit review provides the voluntary sector with an agenda for

action, and there are a number of areas that require greater consideration.

CAF will be at the forefront in tackling these in the near future.

Stuart Etherington, Chief Executive of the National Council for Voluntary

Organisations (NCVO) said today: ‘It is a great boost for the charity sector

that the Government’s Strategy Unit has decided to move in favour of a

universal public benefit test and robust reform of the Charity Commission.

The National Council for Voluntary Organisations believes that it is

essential, in the interest of preserving public trust and confidence in

charities, that these recommendations are enacted through a new Charity Bill

in next years’ Queen’s speech.’

‘It is long overdue that all organisations that wish to become charities as

well as all those already in possession of charitable status should have to

demonstrate the public benefit they provide. Equally significant is the

proposed creation of a Charity Regulation Authority, which will remove the

ambiguity surrounding the Charity Commission’s current dual roles as both

regulator and advisor.’

‘The Government’s Strategy Unit has taken the first step today in updating

our antiquated charity law. This process must not be allowed to stall. We

need a new Charity Bill that introduces a universal public benefit test and

reforms the role of the Charity Commission in next years’ Queen’s speech.

Simplifying the legal definition in this way will clarify the very meaning

of charity and in doing so protect public confidence in the voluntary

sector.’Presently, no universal test of a charity’s public benefit is

demanded by English charity law, which dates back over 400 years. Instead,

this quality is generally presumed to exist in religious organisations and

in organisations that promote education or the relief of poverty.

NCVO will bring further pressure to bear on the Government to enshrine the

Strategy Unit’s recommendations in legislation with the launch of its

campaign for a Charity Bill in the 2003 Queen’s speech. The campaign will be

launched at NCVO’s Fringe Meeting ‘Labour’s second term – a new dawn for

charities’ being held at the Labour party conference on the 2nd of October

which is to be addressed by Paul Boateng MP.

NCVO has already assembled a Charity Law Experts Group which will hold it

first meeting on the 8th October to discuss the details of appropriate

legislation. The Group will be chaired by Lady Winifred Tumim. Lady Tumim

previously chaired the NCVO Charity Law Reform Advisory Group, which argued

for a public benefit test for charities and produced the report ‘For the

Public Benefit?’.

The wait has been worth it!

Private Action, Public Benefit

Report by the Strategy Unit of the Cabinet Office on Å’Charities and the

Wider Not-For-Profit Sector¹.

This remarkable report sets out the most comprehensive, thorough and

authoritative programme of reform for charity law and practice in the

lifetime of any of its readers ­ and it comes with a strong commitment to

implementation, including new legislation.

The Directory of Social Change, as a major provider of information and

support for voluntary organisations, strongly welcomes the recommendations

as a a whole, as well as most of those in specific areas in which DSC has

been campaigning for change

Three reforms stand out.

Public benefit

The proposed new requirement that all charities should show that they are

for public benefit is hugely important. The fact that many charities have

not been Å’charitable¹ at all in the usual sense of the word has been a

blight on the sector for many years, serving to damage the public¹s view

that charity should be there to help those in need.

The call for change is put in forthright terms: Å’Charities which charge

large fees for their services, thereby excluding a substantial part of the

population, will need to demonstrate how their activities have a public

character¹. The report endorses the following tests, among others:

o ‘Charges should be reasonable and should not exclude a substantial

proportion of the beneficiary class

o the service provided should not cater only for the financially well

off. ‘

DSC expects that this change will affect not just public schools but also

quite a number of large private hospitals and clinics, as well as

organisations in other fields.

Charity Registration

The Directory of Social Change has been campaigning against the present

procedures for registration, arguing that they have been made so demanding

that they have become a deterrent to small local groups trying to get

together to do good on a small scale.

DSC therefore welcomes the proposal that charities with an income of less

than £10,000 a year should no longer be registered. This means that 90,000

charities with annual incomes of less than £10,000 will no longer be

registered but, as Small Charities, will still have access to the same tax

relief as registered charities.

For new organisations, the report has accepted DSC¹s view that that

registration is a right for appropriate applicants, and is not dependent on

the Commission¹s views on the viability of their proposed activities.

Legal forms for charities

The present system where most charities that are big enough to employ staff

have to become limited companies, subject to company as well as charity law,

has been a source of constant confusion. The radical proposals for a new

legal form, the Charitable Incorporated Organisation (CIO), with similar

proposals for mutual organisations and social enterprises or community

businesses, will end most of this.

Campaigning

The report calls for clearer and more liberal rules on a charity¹s right to

campaign on behalf of its beneficiaries. This is badly needed as the present

situation is unclear and a number of organisations, seen as wholly

charitable by the public, have been refused charitable status.

The government is consulting this autumn on the implementation of the

report. The Directory of Social change will be consulting with a number of

people including trustees, staff and others, to offer a wholly independent

response. A note on what it sees as issues needing further attention will be

placed shortly on the DSC web site (dsc.org.uk) and anyone interested in is

invited to contribute to this work, by Email or telephone.

COMMENT FROM KINGSTON SMITH’S NOT FOR PROFIT GROUP ON THE STRATEGY UNIT REPORT

Private Action, Public Benefit

The long awaited Strategy Unit Report (formerly the Performance and Innovation Unit)
was published yesterday (September 25, 2002) entitled Private Action, Public Benefit.
The Report which runs to some 97 pages starts by analysing the size and shape of
the charitable and wider not-for-profit sector. One of the interesting statistics
from this section of the Report would indicate that surprisingly enough the number
of not-for-profit organisations in England and Wales per thousand of population 
is slightly below average and countries like Denmark, France, the US and Italy all
have higher percentages.

The Report tells us that the Government’s strategy for the sector has four main 
strands:

Helping charities and other not-for-profit organisations play a bigger role in revitalising
communities and empowering citizens;

Encouraging public support for the sector;

Helping the sector to become more effective and efficient;

and,

Enabling the sector to become a more active partner with Government in shaping policy
and delivery.

One step to achieving that strategy is to reform the legal framework by producing
a modern approach for charities. The existing charitable purposes which have effectively
been with us since 1601 and covered the relief of poverty, advancement of education,
advancement of religion and other purposes beneficial to the community, will be 
replaced by ten new purposes:

Prevention and relief of poverty;

The advancement of education;

The advancement of religion;

The advancement of health;

Social community advancement;

The advancement of culture, arts and heritage;

The advancement of amateur sport;

The promotion of human rights, conflict resolution and reconciliation;

The advancement of environmental protection and improvement;

and,

Other purposes beneficial to the community.

Much of this is not very surprising but the emphasis for charitable purpose will
be on public benefit. The Report states that public benefit has always been presumed
to be present for organisations involved in the relief of poverty and the advancement
of education or religion, unless there is evidence to the contrary. And for charities
with objects that fall under ‘other purposes beneficial to the community’, the concept
of public benefit has to be demonstrated unless it is self-evident. However, the
Report states charities cannot be wholly exonerated from the public benefit requirement
on presumption. All institutions if they are to have charitable status must be demonstrably
established for the public benefit.

A number of charitable sector groupings have been concerned about their future status
as charities since the Charity Commission started reviewing the Register. The Report
states that animal health and welfare will continue to be included under ‘other 
purposes beneficial to the community’. In regard to the advancement of religion 
it is proposed that legislation introducing change to clarify that faiths that are
multi-deity (such as Hinduism), or non-deity (such as some types of Buddhism) should
also qualify under this charitable head. However, it is unlikely that private education
will receive such favourable terms! The Report says that those charities that charge
fees that are not affordable to large sections of the population, unless they make
significant provision for those who cannot pay full fees, may not fall within the
public benefit criteria and thus would be excluded as being a charity. It is proposed
that the Charity Commission will identify charities likely to charge high fees and
undertake a rolling programme to check that provision is made for wider access.

However, to be included within the definition of charity would be those organisations
that emphasise on campaigning, provided that it is of a non-party political nature.

The Report then goes on to outline a number of proposals to make the day to day 
operations of the charities more efficient and reform the legal framework in which
those charities operate.

There is a recommendation that charity law be amended to allow charities to undertake
all trading within the charity without the need for a trading company. There will
be certain duties of care that the Trustees will need to take in this regard, however,
it should increase the transparency by comparing the economic benefits of the trade
with other forms of income generation that the charity undertakes.

The Report recommends that the audit threshold should be increased for charities
with income between £250,000 per annum and £1million per annum. The Independent 
Examination requirement will therefore apply to all charities with income between
£10,000 and £1million.

Another recommendation is that the Charity Commission should provide specific advice
to facilitate mergers possibly by creating a dedicated internal unit.

The Report proposes a range of recommendations to reform the legal framework of 
the sector:

The creation of a new legal form for social enterprises called the ‘Community Interest
Company’, which would protect assets against distribution to members or shareholders
whilst creating a strong new not-for-profit brand for small scale community based
social entrepreneurs;

A revamping of the Industrial & Provident Society legislation to modernise it and
rename such organisations operating within the legislation as Co-operatives and 
Community Benefit Societies;

and,

The creation of a new legal form called a ‘Charitable Incorporated Organisation’
which will replace the existing ‘Companies Limited by Guarantee’.

The Report also discussed the building of public trust and confidence and supporting
the sector in improving performance and suggests that for charities with income 
of over £1million they should complete an annual Standard Information Return which
will highlight qualitative and quantitative information about the charity, focusing
on how it sets it objectives and measures its outcome against these. It also suggests
that the Charities SORP should be amended to improve methods for apportioning costs
and expenditure, enabling more meaningful financial comparisons between organisations
to be made.

As anticipated, but surprisingly little in detail, the Report looked at better regulation
of fundraising. It recommended that a new fundraising body should be established
to develop a self-regulatory initiative. The body would be self financing and would
be based on a new voluntary code of practice designed to promote good practice in
fundraising and to raise awareness of the sector’s commitment to good practice among
the general public. However, the Report does recommend that the Home Secretary should
be given the power to introduce statutory regulations if he considers self-regulation
is ineffective or inadequate!

Finally the Report looked in detail at the role of the Charity Commission and its
regulation of the sector. The main recommendation was that the Charity Commission
should continue to operate at arms length from Government and that it should become
a statutory corporation and be renamed the ‘Charity Regulation Authority’.

As stated in the foreword by the Prime Minister Tony Blair, the Report is issued
as a consultation document and the sector will have time over the next three months
to comment and analyse on the proposals.

The Home Office’s Active Community Unit (ACU) will publish a paper next year setting
out the Government’s next step and strategy for the sector as a whole. It will also
set out an implementation plan for the recommendations arising from this Report.
Many of the recommendations could only be implemented by primary legislation and
it is intended that necessary legislation will be included in a Home Office Bill.

While the Report was worth waiting for, it is probably not as far reaching in comparison
to the time it has taken to produce the Report. However, the sector will benefit
from the recommendations. The jury is still out though on whether actioning all 
the recommendations will have a material effect on the public’s trust and confidence
in the sector.

 * **[The Times criticises political correctness of charity review](https://fundraising.co.uk/2002/09/26/times-criticises-political-correctness-charity-review/)**(
   26 September 2002)
 * **[WaterAid's site reviewed in New Media Age](https://fundraising.co.uk/2002/09/26/wateraid039s-site-reviewed-new-media-age/)**(
   26 September 2002)
 * **[New telephone fundraising agency launches](https://fundraising.co.uk/2002/09/30/new-telephone-fundraising-agency-launches/)**(
   30 September 2002)